American Idol fans are divided over the potential return of Carrie Underwood. She was a judge for the first time last season. However, viewers had a lot of different opinions about her on the show. It seems that production did not like her. However, the ratings went up this last season. So, fans are at a crossroads. There is a lot to unfold and uncover when it comes to this. Keep reading to find out more about this situation.
Carrie Underwood Has First Season As Judge
Carrie Underwood was on American Idol for the first time as a judge last season. However, she was on the show before as a competitor. She ended up winning and making it in the industry. However, she ruffled a lot of feathers during her time as a judge. It was rumored that Luke Bryan had to stand up for her all the time because she was constantly upsetting people. So, no one knew if she was going to return as a judge due to this problem alone. Fans have given their opinions on Carrie all throughout last season. While most viewers liked seeing her on the show because she brought something new to the table, now they are unsure.
American Idol Fans Are At A Divide With Potential Return
Fans are divided when it comes to whether they want Carrie to return as a judge next season or not.
- I don’t know if this was due to Carrie’s influence or just coincidence, but this past season had way too much of a Christian undertone for me. If she is the reason, then she is not a good fit. I watch AI as a secular music show. If religion continues to play a big part next season then I will be done with the show
-
I’m not sure. It didn’t look like she felt comfortable. And at times her critiques were really off. I’d prefer Fantasia as a judge because her short time mentoring did a loooot more than Carrie’s critiques 😭
- Tbh not really. She didn’t seem invested.
-
Nah, I think we should get new judges every season if we can.
Yikes. Most fans do not want to see her return to the show.
It seems as though Carrie Underwood has not completely won fans over. Most are not going to be upset if she does not return next season. However, there are a few who loved her and thought she brought something new to the table. It is unknown right now if Carrie is going to be returning for a second season. What do you think about this situation? Do you want her to return? Sound off in the comments below. We would love to hear your thoughts on this situation.
Hailee is a writer and loves any reality tv show. She is a fur mom and works from home with them by her side.
